Make your own free website on Tripod.com

The Art of lossless image compression, 11th release

Here are the results of 10 tests performed to compare lossless compression
of True Color (24-bit) images by HP Labs' software implementation of JPEG-LS,
by famous and popular PKZIP 2.04g, BOA 0.58b, BMF 0.4, UHIC 1.0,
by some archivers with _special_ algorithms for 24-bit images: Eri32 3.6fre,
Arhangel 1.36, UFA32 0.04b1, RKIVE 1.92b1, UHarc 0.2, ESP 1.92, RAR 2.50b3,
  (sorry, HAP, SZIP, ARJ and all other archivers were not tested)
and results on same images of the famous PNG algorithm and format
created by Display 1.89a, CompuShow 2000! 2.04a, Image Alchemy 1.10.
See Archive Comparison Test by Jeff Gilchrist for more details:
                        http://act.by.net/

If anybody wants to start or continue such tests,
or can suggest some other sets of images, or other compression programs,
     (not sources or algorithm descriptions ; programs for DOS or Windows only)
or knows we have missed something important,
     (some new fantastic technology, an algorithm or even a program capable
      of lossless compression of up to 1000:1 and lossy compression of
      up to 10000:1 , we hear about it from time to time since our XTs)
please let us know immediately: ratush@srsc-gw.sscc.ru   Thank you!


[[1]] Ratio results only

(without details: see also [[2]] Time results [[3]] Details [[4]] Comments) original ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR 274.42 107.48 100% 110.07 121.72 124.67 130.66 118.46 101.13 132.05 284.81 109.31 103.31 112.99 127.68 121.59 166.24 129.11 100% 138.49 237.67 114.40 104.61 109.49 122.49 122.49 155.21 109.92 100% 120.47 234.44 111.10 102.37 108.68 124.19 123.97 153.96 114.11 100% 130.03 253.97 114.30 103.23 110.88 133.26 128.88 164.12 115.42 100% 137.00 221.04 113.03 102.93 108.76 120.05 123.67 129.93 107.69 100% 123.04 253.84 115.51 101.87 108.84 122.43 129.55 135.96 107.95 100% 132.83 275.76 113.44 101.16 107.43 121.05 126.66 140.18 110.30 100% 130.86 221.86 112.15 102.46 107.27 118.37 118.86 143.21 109.06 100% 120.37 535.00 111.47 102.45 105.38 132.89 130.11 147.63 114.89 100% 171.39 JPEG-LS { Display } CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip 148.98 153.44 157.79 157.06 155.20 153.04 153.54 157.72 128.01 168.40 154.08 151.29 183.43 174.57 167.10 162.40 159.93 169.19 126.97 207.39 115.53 141.12 146.51 136.64 137.21 135.24 131.53 138.50 125.07 190.04 125.21 140.16 145.65 143.84 142.90 141.47 137.68 144.58 127.72 182.25 133.28 155.77 154.09 149.62 149.56 148.39 145.79 151.52 133.79 195.80 112.34 136.54 134.31 128.44 132.58 128.76 125.68 134.12 126.48 167.79 113.11 141.81 139.89 134.89 135.18 133.51 130.77 137.70 134.44 173.11 118.45 141.99 142.64 137.20 137.79 135.79 133.03 139.92 131.46 182.33 116.04 135.01 138.66 131.80 133.19 130.61 126.36 134.55 121.14 178.95 144.22 155.78 150.41 160.46 146.83 145.35 143.46 153.41 137.64 191.24

[[2]] Time results

A SET of 23 images totalling 27,133,146 bytes from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/KodakImages/color/ was used for this test, and a Pentium-200mmx PC with 32Mb RAM running windows98 Programs,options Total length Compress_time Extract_time bytes % min:sec % min:sec % Uhic 1.0 m 9887092 100% 11:24 100% 11:37 100% Uhic 1.0 e 10013246 101.27 5:52 51.46 6:02 51.93 BMF 0.4 -f -s -q9 9999232 101.13 23:18 204.38 5:28 47.05 -f -s 10014664 101.29 6:42 58.77 5:24 46.48 -f 10574848 106.95 3:50 33.62 1:21 11.62 Eri32 3.6fre (none) 10626707 107.48 6:36 57.89 1:14 10.61 -m3 10655173 107.76 3:03 26.75 1:14 10.61 -m2 10783096 109.06 2:01 17.69 0:58 8.32 -m1 11270910 113.99 1:37 14.18 0:54 7.74 Arhangel 1.36 -mm 10882776 110.07 4:26 38.88 3:02 26.11 Uharc 0.2 -m3 -md1024 11540085 116.71 16:27 144.29 2:38 22.66 -m3 -md64 11542341 116.74 12:26 109.06 2:39 22.81 -m2 -md64 11620441 117.53 8:42 76.31 2:43 23.38 -m1 -md64 11648316 117.81 7:32 66.08 2:45 23.67 Rkive 1.92b1 -mt3 11711160 118.44 5:41 49.85 5:50 50.21 -mt1 11711171 118.44 5:42 50.00 5:55 50.93 -mf3 11711196 118.44 5:23 47.22 5:54 50.78 -mf1 11711220 118.44 5:54 51.75 6:26 55.38 BOA 0.58b -m15 12035317 121.72 27:41 242.83 28:57 249.21 -m1 12701997 128.47 14:12 124.56 15:55 137.01 Ufa32 0.04b1 -m4 -mq 12306443 124.46 6:34 57.60 6:39 57.24 -m4 -mx 12326992 124.67 18:17 160.38 6:01 51.79 -m5 -mu16 12918549 130.66 19:08 167.83 20:20 175.03 Esp 1.92 /m0 /mm2 /ml7 12660409 128.04 2:53 25.29 0:19 2.72 /m2 /mm2 /ml7 12697833 128.42 2:05 18.27 0:18 2.58 /m3 /mm2 /ml7 13625893 137.81 1:31 13.30 0:20 2.86 Rar 2.50b3 -m5 -mm -s 13276706 134.28 1:48 15.78 1:01 8.75 -m5 -mm -s- 13298985 134.50 1:48 15.78 1:00 8.60 -m3 -mm -s 13280593 134.32 1:42 14.91 1:00 8.60 -m1 -mm -s 13304170 134.56 1:40 14.61 1:01 8.75 Pkzip 2.04g -ex 16650031 168.40 1:37 14.18 0:24 3.44 (none) 16741609 169.32 1:00 8.77 0:24 3.44 -es 19818636 200.44 0:33 4.82 0:23 3.29 Locoe 0.90 -N 14730521 148.98 1:10 10.23 1:13 10.47 -N -c2 14770163 149.38 1:15 10.96 1:11 10.18 Display -i --same -bpng filter=5,level=9 15131718 153.04 4:13 36.98 0:38 5.45 filter=1,level=9 15171412 153.44 3:53 34.06 0:33 4.73 filter=1,level=5 15493033 156.69 1:27 12.71 0:33 4.73 filter=1,level=1 15876308 160.57 1:01 8.91 0:36 5.16 Alchemy ---n (4) 15594095 157.72 6:15 54.82 1:41 14.49 CompuShow 2000! (auto) 15181076 153.54 2:46 24.26 1:08 9.75 This set, losslessly compressed with Eri32 3.6fre to 10,177,326 bytes, can be downloaded from http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/5577/ or ftp://vmk.iae.nsk.su/Public/Eri/ or ftp://ftp.inp.nsk.su/export/eri/ or ftp://ftp.itam.nsc.ru/incoming/ or ftp://poctok.iae.nsk.su/incoming/eri/ Decompression time is about 60 seconds on a Pentium-200mmx PC.

[[3]] Details

1,2,3,4,9 image sets were taken from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/ and /image2/ converted from Sun Raster format to Windows Bitmap, (this conversion changes image headers only, 32 bytes are replaced by 54 bytes, but image data is not modified) and some of them were slightly renamed. This site ipl.rpi.edu is described in comp.copression FAQ by Jean-loup Gailly, in 29 lines of "Subject: [55] Where can I find Lenna and other images?" Five images in the 5th set are from the famous Waterloo Color Set, (losslessly compressed with Eri32 3.6fre to 2,931,298 bytes, it can be found at http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Bay/1995/ ) 6,7,8 image sets are from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/ 10th set was taken from ftp://ftp.kodak.com/www/images/dental/ and converted from TIFF format to Windows Bitmap. (1) All files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/KodakImages/color/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf KODAK01 498060 471838 503690 593063 575502 590906 538014 475076 595993 KODAK02 442355 406342 450122 505024 531260 439934 500679 427796 564770 KODAK03 380506 326856 380775 390747 441769 412274 424125 359624 480369 KODAK04 449275 427418 465399 508996 526885 557447 504805 426368 562528 KODAK05 550811 519749 561713 649772 630250 739824 593500 494600 659195 KODAK06 456471 432662 476884 494633 507010 546193 499287 439028 522167 KODAK07 408180 356649 412046 437483 483495 468772 455913 378320 525150 KODAK08 554403 525000 552336 693702 660714 741600 586000 516408 797076 KODAK09 429390 384185 437961 476102 508401 475975 499096 405992 542117 KODAK10 438821 406236 446037 486401 514986 515338 503117 409960 542635 KODAK11 441691 412801 458878 499095 508580 548463 488586 425664 540885 KODAK12 402433 359135 409865 414974 456336 442726 459630 381224 492127 KODAK13 585329 568801 609213 689853 644274 745314 640626 555384 657081 KODAK14 500728 473674 515875 564700 557968 645182 547914 473328 583175 KODAK15 446933 393312 438726 500823 535094 512018 470891 402392 584881 KODAK16 406711 368367 423156 420949 448005 422389 460266 396164 462303 KODAK17 432856 400421 443420 484425 507603 497876 481967 410308 532935 KODAK18 555115 535404 579634 648744 625941 741250 608728 514528 655754 KODAK19 474601 451977 488855 556103 556370 577562 524800 450760 581968 KODAK20 357085 333914 379498 400208 457466 411891 373942 332164 457656 KODAK21 471634 448988 495716 523827 525849 556198 530295 453272 541205 KODAK22 515451 487998 525884 611779 606701 709648 557212 474276 628545 KODAK23 427868 395365 427181 484090 516709 619945 463614 396596 545563 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 23 10626707 98870921088286412035493123271681291872511713007 999923213056078 274.42 107.48 100% 110.07 121.72 124.67 130.66 118.46 101.13 132.05 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 773505 760243 785332 781283 742508 744472 762998 752856 587325 828292 596758 637806 631332 640438 641660 628700 623734 650267 542767 646034 514026 506472 552842 545028 552492 545043 545256 565998 457345 552355 617012 640129 649547 650814 651324 650047 644746 660662 543302 723526 761566 805327 814347 793711 799815 790801 797555 813402 647135 875717 670912 631185 730872 690743 673603 647047 659763 684451 520054 737475 536896 560317 605119 601086 576780 577133 574779 589557 501425 636420 775450 859827 818692 859875 772006 771221 776922 784527 674455 891165 586802 622086 602937 631443 615120 604798 604043 624622 523245 668032 587854 627165 612863 630447 624075 622986 620906 633997 528640 695882 646756 630792 678618 665875 650179 629707 632324 662138 520871 676451 563272 533855 587442 579178 575505 572357 571824 586269 472659 582646 873003 859453 893400 864888 875111 860933 877739 889163 655363 885606 723103 702857 755415 726264 728531 723441 727468 739422 575922 790025 573127 627321 602857 624318 623391 620407 617728 635627 551918 682665 599228 541290 635649 605486 599170 566271 572778 608718 460166 565643 609027 629130 619624 631592 638803 631751 632073 649573 521333 701272 749039 794914 802504 781041 796841 781199 778873 807820 642608 886756 666411 712888 717644 726334 697335 696470 697516 706185 571151 792877 451240 499339 521502 508982 514091 505651 506171 526609 468697 563411 666573 652334 709780 691157 689787 675154 681773 698358 537016 682803 667885 742482 709990 715696 718174 711990 704754 726295 620140 831781 521076 594200 563001 583480 588854 574139 569353 597577 533771 753681 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 4730521151714121560130915529159153451551513171815181076155940931265730816650515 148.98 153.44 157.79 157.06 155.20 153.04 153.54 157.72 128.01 168.40 (2) All files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/mobile/color/ +some files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/football/color/ +some files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/susie/color/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mm MOBILE01 644072 601403 635466 730616 677281 853087 670485 559668 707837 MOBILE02 643996 600928 634630 730778 677510 852874 669883 559164 707730 FOOTBAL0 411563 394133 429609 476791 451321 620334 500978 385088 528677 FOOTBAL1 417771 393725 435047 481187 454627 635043 502106 386224 532953 FOOTBAL2 418858 396613 438034 487099 460471 651591 500297 389124 536298 FOOTBAL3 422999 400041 441982 492919 467827 663840 506800 392400 544646 FOOTBA50 438401 415937 464485 507673 487021 713040 521612 407408 577037 FOOTBA70 437163 409966 464864 512640 491761 715850 514596 403520 580861 FOOTBA96 444751 415562 472712 515647 495519 716817 524424 409072 589896 SUSIE000 331014 312382 342965 403551 386931 530683 409065 305144 439348 SUSIE001 330863 312856 342640 400335 384071 526528 410529 305588 435958 SUSIE002 330942 312774 343027 397782 382040 523333 410810 304932 432825 SUSIE003 330463 312228 341930 399578 383245 526068 410128 304920 434096 SUSIE050 304246 302084 318950 338763 341090 442665 385788 286560 398955 SUSIE100 326279 309141 336821 394354 378959 505415 404707 300832 431843 SUSIE149 327921 311682 339152 394169 378936 501360 407420 302584 433630 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 16 6561302 6201455 6782314 7663882 7298610 9978528 7749628 6002228 8312590 284.81 109.31 103.31 112.99 127.68 121.59 166.24 129.11 100% 138.49 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 737220 847418 857156 816610 824787 812052 792052 832912 699840 996813 736475 847429 856356 816209 824269 812081 792007 832481 700015 996138 609889 552015 773986 709796 635611 589882 584153 643356 471341 771899 608613 557619 767461 703760 642049 600418 594893 650086 475628 785519 615612 563825 773690 711597 642054 624059 611959 650229 481351 799375 620661 570556 774274 713995 648738 620492 612278 656871 489102 808949 636853 593331 791003 732346 671132 639254 636214 681384 511074 857312 625815 599653 756117 707836 671512 659895 649233 681684 516218 856338 633771 605772 772304 720652 680299 662265 655700 690920 521042 859166 493256 493651 543563 549914 547873 546490 536797 554238 405150 693540 495257 490402 547459 548882 550114 547246 538092 556638 402008 690959 497127 486889 552220 548266 552319 546494 537948 558836 399418 688775 495243 488755 546754 547171 549566 545898 536843 555949 400859 690983 466916 416466 618682 566008 500796 461186 459994 508653 356121 618084 485791 483780 536510 541776 541587 538536 529164 547709 396354 669767 490235 483376 542581 543858 547083 541715 532483 553293 396105 664913 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 9248734 9080937110101161047867610029789 9747963 959981010155239 762162612448530 154.08 151.29 183.43 174.57 167.10 162.40 159.93 169.19 126.97 207.39 (3) Two files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/sequence/missa/color/ +all files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/canon/bgr/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf MISSA000 120091 103370 109912 145753 140714 176549 122299 105068 152841 MISSA001 120343 103421 110046 146000 140993 176696 122427 105260 153321 ANNOUNCE 293556 286513 286912 322874 310525 457800 322185 268532 307527 BEACHGIR 357306 314018 330018 372977 381417 452529 320050 298480 378203 BLUEGIRL 354087 313165 328008 377693 384613 448509 321309 299736 388317 CABLECAR 383969 347294 368781 400460 403505 485065 365002 332872 402898 CORNFILD 417683 382958 410459 442348 423552 518820 405213 367036 404302 FLOWER 365240 335032 346688 390062 397404 507245 345913 320656 380311 FRUITS 385896 355275 378204 421102 439479 560392 365380 339824 396787 GIRL 387577 344537 359258 408793 414900 480936 352795 332516 409125 GIRL_LDI 271599 273009 270019 294548 284316 448589 303743 251524 280159 HUSTLER 274894 268867 273604 311713 302103 450660 302485 255256 298222 KIDS 389365 358779 377855 424419 416101 554135 373977 344056 412937 MASUDA1 323304 285734 307292 328749 337932 428216 295552 275180 332324 MASUDA2 331973 284551 307687 335682 341849 402801 290739 277256 350569 MODEL 351388 320627 332418 375836 377403 449791 330972 303132 370158 PENS 390671 365472 381861 417113 417052 522818 376406 341344 405836 SOCCER 415525 390215 411247 451039 447179 551651 406268 372116 430973 TANAKA 370260 333658 345728 381476 385017 457172 340917 321520 373095 YACHT 383243 349344 364957 412432 414476 543267 362551 334408 414636 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 20 6687970 6115839 6400954 7161069 7160530 9073641 6426183 5845772 7042541 237.67 114.40 104.61 109.49 122.49 122.49 155.21 109.92 100% 120.47 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 145828 164670 155933 168064 158340 153834 151134 160093 144887 204738 146082 164898 156279 168148 158357 154599 151789 160165 145273 204849 360545 394567 473888 415512 408902 403245 395135 411862 322899 577479 327231 423334 412660 391039 407785 393588 384170 410951 389428 570444 331584 433607 410999 398965 407156 403892 392684 410951 392986 579880 374861 456895 473116 444428 440808 440729 427424 448497 414165 563795 421678 490102 511382 474188 475316 469217 459528 480543 432847 588760 358924 448168 454710 425850 433366 428146 415239 436372 404043 630722 379801 474575 480014 451997 455717 454068 438730 460456 446386 640889 365802 464427 452646 435194 442893 435589 421726 446502 422505 594308 341551 360142 455789 390335 387854 381594 374292 390401 294611 602537 328019 380955 434289 387143 388499 384091 377135 391096 314310 567875 390954 481279 500974 466533 459339 458988 444011 464240 423660 638084 303238 387201 404260 372613 380518 375563 365855 384643 343353 553789 297715 390500 395078 369158 379715 373482 364025 384600 347952 521313 339914 431888 422529 401017 416146 404357 394723 418826 382280 570636 391466 481108 497853 447747 466580 447253 432936 471139 423328 647471 426145 517837 542931 501348 490592 490158 472749 496012 455397 640108 348841 429430 433749 408289 419682 410397 396897 422516 389032 584793 373720 474291 495830 470450 443661 443344 429185 446822 422294 627102 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 6753899 8249874 8564909 7988018 8021226 7906134 7689367 8096687 731163611109572 115.53 141.12 146.51 136.64 137.21 135.24 131.53 138.50 125.07 190.04 (4) All files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/jpeg/bgr/ +all files from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image/still/usc/bgr/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf BARB 497860 483760 531197 657748 623620 904301 604975 467496 704650 BOATS 438387 430858 446973 542407 537181 727272 528847 411376 593276 FRUITS 215351 181604 197062 203570 211116 212022 189764 192596 307687 GIRL 447870 432591 469312 563993 555090 803663 539012 415204 627049 GOLD 499058 482396 511444 605518 579278 842054 603663 474876 649551 ZELDA 442705 427690 446506 540828 527105 842322 548344 410472 588827 AIRPLANE 398847 360889 383844 423886 421730 461825 378311 353592 422648 BABOON 608494 570677 602923 631651 621137 704634 592779 560436 615548 COUPLE 105798 94290 99993 113021 112913 119406 97455 93688 114931 GIRL2 120515 107351 113080 124256 123209 134127 109840 103716 122880 GIRL2A 83994 77227 81622 89801 88316 96994 82331 74896 89735 GIRL3 100327 90316 94458 115421 113987 140847 94203 87112 116585 HOUSE 109486 98166 104862 114676 112902 128496 101904 97524 111944 JELLY_B1 71645 58908 63390 75041 82349 94678 62761 56640 77583 JELLY_B2 79543 66670 71620 84767 91151 108981 70698 63796 87453 LENA 463314 417992 438142 499070 501341 590125 434387 409716 497103 PEPPERS 526873 455457 478761 527180 525557 632442 464144 445744 525872 SAILBOAT 550583 496967 526082 563378 562754 615289 510078 483656 556615 SPLASH 372783 333376 356040 408244 428886 473289 343283 327692 407307 TIFFANY 415874 367434 389023 446648 501201 473622 377416 363208 465041 TREE 126220 116593 123549 131059 128265 144296 122302 114892 130847 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 21 6675527 6151212 6529883 7462163 7449088 9250685 6856497 6008328 7813132 234.44 111.10 102.37 108.68 124.19 123.97 153.96 114.11 100% 130.03 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 756303 801657 844690 869236 839921 836267 825410 850293 655412 1043504 652761 663594 735246 751381 721857 717395 703767 729143 559659 878505 193198 215187 221901 219826 224439 214763 210006 230611 222289 228571 647536 674463 734167 747197 729864 728183 708304 736497 577270 941825 728368 703759 834153 810019 785172 792118 767605 794911 603360 1020962 642009 642772 711385 723397 719402 714993 694772 725492 548426 1002196 389570 481880 476710 453687 461920 452661 440948 465802 429894 573566 606790 649148 671834 638474 645418 635853 628498 657721 628696 750571 98891 124453 121225 118504 116204 116122 112133 117535 114468 138303 110774 132944 133375 128088 129940 127782 122779 131095 125013 152986 84370 103189 106972 101484 103086 101076 98850 103109 91277 118016 95800 127754 116480 118029 114403 113959 110394 114824 115859 164979 102865 125128 129865 122707 121116 120143 115102 121723 114892 152084 60244 88143 81727 79848 80533 79881 77398 80698 87303 116168 68145 97660 93341 89855 89518 89160 87269 90228 96731 129448 446342 546336 519624 515416 520455 511607 490338 526650 506640 718337 468393 556561 550873 539867 548381 538306 515706 556188 539321 725095 514920 589080 591736 569432 580331 568217 552320 589642 579973 710997 352392 455799 444223 429709 432410 429163 417423 436280 436801 622259 380119 500987 484057 477876 482077 474714 459008 487271 509769 595951 123536 141217 147602 138749 140050 137737 134417 141213 130967 166228 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 7523326 8421711 8751186 8642781 8586497 8500100 8272447 8686926 767402010950551 125.21 140.16 145.65 143.84 142.90 141.47 137.68 144.58 127.72 182.25 (5) Five (natural) images from http://links.uwaterloo.ca/colorset.base.html +the largest .BMP from Corel Draw! 6.0 package +test image from Archive Comparison Test by Jeff Gilchrist ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf LENA 462682 416809 437715 498738 500734 590064 433712 408948 496511 MONARCH 480358 423263 462544 550123 564927 675992 500694 410792 601034 PEPPERS 339328 325729 337034 389603 382418 575568 357134 308544 407245 SAIL 564701 519134 567080 680027 627490 759177 590602 498820 648308 TULIPS 549707 488386 525216 662595 652914 849334 551537 464896 663406 MONCALIB 198304 177635 187944 217215 208430 254910 189853 174572 219254 ACTEST4 130010 110240 125816 178660 135570 207634 128270 117388 230448 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 7 2725090 2461196 2643349 3176961 3072483 3912679 2751802 2383960 3266206 253.97 114.30 103.23 110.88 133.26 128.88 164.12 115.42 100% 137.00 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 445799 546042 519398 514920 520428 511347 490084 526564 505918 718477 555012 666020 660412 633685 644417 636546 628936 654171 593009 833559 385047 459518 485613 453808 451894 451397 440335 455723 404768 663990 767374 816430 845283 791128 800850 794585 794017 810839 642393 918368 616536 768660 733790 713744 709048 707486 692286 717979 683870 981793 205111 243777 239406 235846 235055 233358 228875 238380 212537 281578 202652 213179 189612 223843 203962 202857 201116 208718 147150 270079 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 3177531 3713626 3673514 3566974 3565654 3537576 3475649 3612374 3189645 4667844 133.28 155.77 154.09 149.62 149.56 148.39 145.79 151.52 133.79 195.80 (6) All files from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/bios/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf AYMAR 696039 654136 714211 828718 843846 917541 725386 633172 830044 BARRETT 638400 604530 653040 730640 693852 797745 671335 584428 704427 CARTER 643276 605087 656203 728387 696800 786312 659921 588204 717868 CRAWFORD 708970 678767 719380 798966 764799 872958 734620 649140 807998 DUNLAP 638026 606378 661822 760077 691032 852237 678502 579872 775084 DYESS 588209 550284 610589 715979 659885 825057 611869 523372 739518 GILL 707959 674949 717510 793777 808528 846223 727108 648432 808840 GROVE 654904 620461 674171 762379 776705 812290 702998 607044 765060 HOWE 858376 785816 824855 944329 976108 1125899 809343 775060 964134 KINNIE 648094 613682 657581 729942 750935 810602 669288 590724 740853 MALONEY 931685 820500 851495 955864 1005841 1091148 825704 801724 989523 GELSNGER 721036 683576 732814 814056 836921 921988 748025 659820 824990 MOORE 634097 593594 650471 734015 684783 796763 655664 577256 757855 MINER 878037 806190 865978 964031 983675 1050042 852228 783504 960032 MILLER 723268 688335 732950 806902 780009 859392 744181 664368 776794 NACHTSHM 614315 580975 629742 711965 732740 790525 645746 560824 729990 OTELLINI 681208 650583 691460 762603 780172 827235 707779 622076 771380 PARKER 609040 575265 623403 695953 719920 756175 633523 555048 714996 BARRET1 1461747 1321024 1424278 1581428 1705813 1632129 1366430 1303268 1637685 GROVEBW 810339 756857 777724 896515 897319 953922 814728 706628 909427 POLLACK 1204623 1108359 1151870 1255071 1290415 1254061 1152594 1043860 1290921 RSMITH 1102336 1007652 1057011 1230461 1288527 1454418 1034056 959348 1258946 VADASZ 586271 554231 597209 684968 701951 784938 613756 533348 689578 WHITTIER 631564 600489 650702 737345 683646 809016 669377 580180 747467 YU 611230 578959 625997 703195 666946 770080 636665 555600 679793 YU1 1155779 1040684 1093810 1216155 1258360 1552003 1056432 1010700 1220931 GEYER 759146 708578 737253 833007 935786 916518 772151 680536 892558 WHETSTON 746978 686537 731550 840916 820698 909573 753840 664500 866626 LBURNS 1150351 1069138 1139406 1226717 1253029 1363962 1104094 1045760 1237401 RATTNER 1529024 1393805 1429989 1540274 1580685 1729533 1421342 1375792 1537687 AYMAR2 1455302 1302740 1382613 1533250 1592374 1605216 1351935 1284116 1627628 CARTER2 1236311 1079488 1155957 1250286 1349495 1275745 1124606 1062968 1303166 CRWFRD2 1565042 1411943 1489854 1656319 1767067 1769703 1471139 1390236 1749264 DAVIES 1114794 1010538 1043671 1131301 1158788 1253274 1031824 998332 1134953 GELSNG2 1536366 1402622 1458512 1610827 1661982 1675151 1453546 1375604 1622379 GILL2 1604423 1460499 1528446 1667879 1753794 1636282 1496064 1450016 1738609 KONAR 1296263 1146703 1197329 1275306 1381762 1338149 1183079 1129944 1356996 MOORE2 1694014 1504366 1581218 1667660 1801023 1549876 1524693 1359132 1735853 OTELIN2 1164393 1003194 1064500 1161563 1281035 1122287 1056954 985328 1333364 PARKER2 1508066 1357845 1434979 1583087 1685784 1679772 1404062 1335816 1687919 SODHANI 1333967 1227918 1283727 1415798 1462269 1591455 1241244 1194772 1432548 WHTIER2 1491934 1346199 1421227 1552770 1622317 1654740 1381604 1318380 1590070 BRYANT 798840 732294 789481 883768 892164 1010494 756743 714084 889740 CBARRET 5735216 5024181 5215545 5574707 5795143 5958852 5056096 4888072 5703983 CHRISTN 1317331 1174754 1211327 1318947 1382943 1490630 1184597 1142912 1350817 FISTER 1482858 1329746 1415851 1528285 1579055 1619104 1381773 1308988 1547586 LEGLISE 792054 723792 758412 851232 871449 1027630 738454 709648 850614 SAINI 724185 655043 686210 765186 776505 846279 673466 645452 791819 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 48 521756864751328650203333554128065708467559974924497105644615738856795714 221.04 113.03 102.93 108.76 120.05 123.67 129.93 107.69 100% 123.04 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 813200 941708 910662 874482 897551 876687 862365 906778 871373 1131625 725194 835238 827470 785923 824341 791112 775873 831175 704072 1023391 713028 835103 833462 790759 822979 796199 779672 831334 706057 1007877 788220 905956 901573 857255 894298 856960 834412 904218 774664 1106989 787810 892040 876160 828070 869523 829950 826074 879211 699667 1094058 696115 833729 795905 743277 791608 748777 739644 797707 669990 1059417 780311 895870 892978 851498 887907 850928 827469 898328 833391 1063510 798247 882923 889729 837859 861982 840794 837435 873947 803683 989071 832069 1061601 1008403 978468 1001710 980424 955530 1012685 998461 1420534 721159 834422 828511 785503 825096 785487 768316 832704 774110 1031308 850528 1085985 1045311 1004966 1043341 1009537 986231 1052480 1030891 1398411 817336 933555 938273 884956 925710 885970 866970 933878 862581 1160095 729713 849381 836674 802870 828937 805789 791682 837583 694463 1025675 905815 1082515 1053897 1017145 1046176 1018896 998604 1057885 1012059 1306582 799314 910332 914939 875029 905030 874383 850178 916571 791617 1055811 715046 826420 820478 770875 812331 774499 762090 819383 758936 1021890 759533 864409 866387 820012 862322 819948 799404 871306 805261 1056089 691673 805480 800113 753466 796727 756029 742337 803674 744639 976816 1396395 1777008 1741249 1691593 1700919 1685321 1646662 1723964 1759656 2068946 862093 1087937 1020915 969311 1032748 976331 967419 1044660 916485 1379440 1207469 1448912 1429084 1380216 1439085 1381555 1342158 1456506 1342958 1647711 1078646 1407034 1345816 1285825 1322227 1286631 1260853 1335134 1322291 1888042 663231 785981 777537 730097 763929 736418 723542 769939 723747 1022847 754092 855754 848806 801022 839389 804287 793957 848181 691862 1045978 686791 799283 794058 749272 786384 751261 736431 794068 678042 990965 1088541 1345533 1356198 1276696 1301186 1276985 1234239 1314355 1284073 1873248 784555 1013164 1006960 933287 976173 951887 945511 997662 974857 1302419 849771 999370 979410 925631 966020 933094 935454 982934 837282 1201185 1138325 1384423 1361715 1301021 1342358 1304926 1264049 1356628 1267270 1712626 1448848 1662769 1652295 1591887 1645927 1590261 1504292 1665982 1615682 2129072 1361463 1789655 1737754 1676407 1699816 1669780 1633480 1724384 1620097 2107945 1125560 1454952 1455994 1370462 1421266 1382633 1355135 1441649 1373453 1729742 1519261 1919715 1853885 1799638 1805201 1795054 1741962 1827610 1809828 2292388 1044662 1235701 1220771 1176646 1211034 1175810 1120400 1224644 1180212 1560408 1491758 1833734 1783428 1714591 1776609 1716222 1664686 1794634 1693425 2300106 1536644 1886600 1843171 1789007 1808316 1788098 1715946 1828492 1785139 2192002 1182498 1517088 1514229 1423141 1465371 1441098 1412437 1480760 1408255 1919589 1530960 1826536 1826988 1794785 1833251 1794057 1719906 1859061 1831954 2050885 1033410 1386533 1369438 1315175 1345148 1329032 1303881 1369480 1313163 1583501 1439803 1854199 1756721 1716940 1738804 1723727 1671547 1758544 1726430 2294892 1270385 1571121 1554355 1459929 1520382 1460415 1413256 1534491 1491089 2039586 1413290 1778683 1754581 1666651 1710783 1673331 1626458 1728514 1643201 2167249 792232 1003880 966127 922455 955194 926828 904157 964451 903392 1301344 5150041 6138740 6106748 5869097 6046147 5864995 5810580 6118680 5954658 7521348 1197585 1471270 1452287 1391303 1444445 1390508 1336039 1459491 1411781 1859797 1421924 1676426 1656580 1594297 1636270 1594309 1543448 1659958 1614284 1952678 761065 958569 929184 889272 920036 894078 869979 928538 881902 1300129 698966 878232 856880 820835 846568 831022 812482 854053 789305 1086808 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1854575630254696199408959288902611985555943232358014632619082945838168877452025 112.34 136.54 134.31 128.44 132.58 128.76 125.68 134.12 126.48 167.79 (7) All images from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/processors/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf L17B-34 2471805 2242010 2355938 2762455 2858786 3435223 2260004 2151824 2770741 L217B-7 2188309 1954422 2054170 2359541 2572092 2575697 2002606 1905300 2555201 L217C-2 2168454 1893725 2005221 2359970 2534693 2966470 1932419 1850300 2536577 L17C-34 2458878 2175634 2318590 2571871 2699598 3082578 2212598 2163920 2689049 AL440LX 780264 701497 746082 868072 945798 931918 762615 714148 1299131 D012698 2345102 2019769 2106594 1507760 2272037 2560463 2044841 1988956 2260451 D050797 1384777 1281711 1348504 1156429 1603637 1604344 1353221 1223172 1580088 D081897 1121824 978186 1070254 2291444 1283461 1152770 1057017 946072 1285618 D20797A 1460784 1364373 1377676 1745456 1694246 2054255 1484222 1312652 1748069 D41598C 1664266 1450374 1562626 1683899 1680131 1707096 1522284 1380172 1759920 MMX 825868 740387 782205 920776 1041691 1080486 792589 711088 1059047 MMX3 1089334 901992 1004085 1043059 1144407 993654 992667 849416 1214453 MMX4 1020866 953707 992039 1114842 1110062 1163478 1011033 901604 1166414 MP02177 1312951 1180616 1240600 1339345 1445300 1524670 1225363 1151268 1441457 MP4029A 1416547 1102430 1270208 1384212 1520542 1215331 1279772 727668 1530328 MP4029B 1590667 1305841 1548577 1603058 1684823 1376856 1615878 871016 1794373 MP9087A 811242 754254 799951 897729 1055344 1021308 843191 1193348 1190223 MP9087B 1000104 909904 963781 1126789 1261041 1465132 944557 1428172 1295446 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 18 271120422391083225547101287367073040768931911729253368772347009631176586 253.84 115.51 101.87 108.84 122.43 129.55 135.96 107.95 100% 132.83 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 2389965 3128519 2977080 2854977 2832124 2825107 2722585 2865028 2957657 4117314 2070229 2742596 2581092 2560918 2456139 2459243 2391406 2497244 2655170 3252025 1968320 2760700 2647982 2572706 2488258 2487050 2431603 2536124 2628711 3852498 2279454 2865853 2827534 2722610 2697831 2689349 2585162 2735536 2777349 3657977 849114 1051048 1043560 1031703 995584 990095 978799 1009926 1000638 1179467 2086646 2454762 2461298 2368030 2427459 2365599 2269797 2462798 2310563 3019797 1485673 1728703 1736014 1648525 1685665 1660985 1631405 1714750 1659268 2039666 1097173 1355045 1339883 1281322 1332376 1294907 1293130 1361378 1352810 1565553 1559638 1928034 1942367 1863861 1734908 1734899 1680372 1756995 1726206 2329473 1602046 1968801 1959661 1860906 1936626 1879185 1865336 1968411 1744969 2294107 812645 1120112 1033317 1015838 1012864 1011704 1004292 1043846 1086999 1493058 992197 1253516 1293643 1208297 1269880 1236608 1231754 1306469 1213356 1359115 1102983 1323827 1315328 1261956 1285579 1272914 1257878 1304576 1145075 1568001 1248780 1581706 1632889 1519667 1566777 1552965 1534452 1598472 1498104 2067519 946184 1632371 1631276 1599892 1642674 1592660 1578561 1683935 1578790 1699654 998465 1966619 2036986 1978874 2047874 1982444 1965492 2080391 1755201 2013524 1314244 1092889 1080658 1067926 1068545 1063726 1059267 1110411 1143257 1298976 1744318 1328885 1293899 1242296 1247912 1235891 1212884 1283932 1321228 1822110 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 6548074332839863283446731660304317290753133533130694175323202223155535140629834 113.11 141.81 139.89 134.89 135.18 133.51 130.77 137.70 134.44 173.11 (8) All images from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/imaging/ +all natural images from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/internet/ +all images from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/misc/ +all images from ftp://download.intel.com/pressroom/images/videoconferencing/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mm P020598 1295228 856008 1206830 1149077 1427940 762901 1442503 1190480 1323362 PI1397A 1184777 1087049 1142718 1265641 1328579 1485864 1124500 1056860 1309037 PI1397B 1762648 1551111 1628975 1880575 1933615 2449620 1569881 1496060 1896916 PI11397C 834758 748707 800168 929696 1024950 1153552 796710 739156 1364651 IN3119A 1677053 1437806 1498114 1696660 1847195 2012718 1504515 1406868 1867386 IN3119B 1703327 1476530 1549200 1747711 1814987 1991058 1559763 1426504 1882546 IN3119C 1826903 1708704 1783702 1964283 2042517 2087989 1847590 1675024 2099834 ISVRBOX 542247 483176 517338 570691 630867 672231 521566 525856 755011 ARCADE 2187988 1929319 2003891 2204762 2290528 2521385 1950865 1887760 2259374 ARCADE1 1368619 1229550 1283262 1400813 1452302 1568002 1246233 1194840 1429635 ARCADE2 1231093 1120435 1165764 1264371 1297545 1380695 1140324 1101232 1278150 AW1197_1 759954 723017 737734 906355 915209 1281861 792171 690200 974417 AW197_5 1492817 1402180 1426127 1884728 1897403 2391217 1502210 1321928 2002110 CANYONRN 366123 308928 325909 378220 384539 539373 349895 298984 432004 CARPC 1376761 1243056 1299002 1496888 1536380 1943876 1328955 1181728 1582771 I010698 1522314 1403732 1508698 1701728 1648701 2027968 1559112 1342980 1732200 PERIPH 1011583 881040 1010680 1063005 1248198 906370 1114237 974304 1190106 SHIFTY 178837 177653 185028 207395 204580 248792 282223 168912 341222 C020998 2517470 2384132 2498574 2684411 2769203 2961127 2484359 2302848 2721577 PS020397 901105 769987 846643 927326 934387 937685 856255 786672 1056004 P060297 1076923 968395 1012483 1181397 1184291 1328678 1030843 943808 1283113 P091597 1513257 1353598 1453307 1610751 1718968 1992081 1404958 1351448 1725427 P91597B 1457977 1264991 1324924 1535547 1541844 1781794 1319879 1232084 1604721 V121197 1083251 1006140 1033150 1356180 1309010 1913586 1131891 949504 1438712 V42798A 1485144 1304944 1348006 1490571 1553690 1895974 1418162 1255620 1604855 V42798B 1263522 1173050 1249932 1374125 1536680 1370482 1360465 1110716 1621222 VC42798C 178810 147591 168855 193215 263209 159740 223196 181208 212254 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 27 338004893014082932009014360661223773731741766619328632612979358438988617 275.76 113.44 101.16 107.43 121.05 126.66 140.18 110.30 100% 130.86 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c1 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 1638517 1518487 1674339 1722240 1691598 1704551 1694396 1729356 1474057 1307758 1174941 1475577 1449755 1366876 1419898 1381079 1352533 1435011 1362674 2060723 1608408 2131906 2074568 1991484 1964145 1949315 1888431 1982907 1983967 2957440 853534 1097699 1086527 1055857 1024142 1021764 1002451 1041436 1070657 1386971 1547017 1979892 2007819 1884645 1946908 1883462 1852031 1981986 1932857 2645991 1622284 2062481 2063930 1957771 2016387 1972087 1944155 2055895 1884471 2683853 1973549 2283557 2364069 2246527 2266657 2201631 2151467 2290580 2142864 2766700 530392 684253 695561 680919 672065 667082 655626 683469 655196 843808 1986926 2443474 2411478 2326619 2350706 2318441 2212784 2377182 2330540 3166231 1259211 1494319 1493905 1443209 1455044 1436330 1373897 1477815 1481399 1858966 1149402 1326990 1320888 1284743 1301254 1279139 1229048 1322717 1325418 1623276 878467 1083179 1114990 1064474 1006610 1006610 984382 1021357 961393 1497018 1661785 2202964 1954482 2019828 1937304 1936388 1896574 1970401 1961660 2892003 359944 452789 509227 452958 438029 436950 431838 448997 410041 671206 1389907 1810467 1787099 1699246 1691885 1689358 1664182 1720653 1576543 2542808 1722140 2049229 2038029 1918082 1971700 1940203 1913922 1995392 1691410 2694195 1277520 1326811 1425598 1388890 1400797 1385471 1363417 1419511 1306265 1256719 399138 282605 380915 370167 381038 375546 378097 393203 213567 406978 2594493 2968093 3002231 2865831 2928196 2859380 2763665 2970951 2853588 3722091 1046351 1166981 1141545 1126485 1104507 1098993 1099156 1113910 1015642 1353274 1107314 1397820 1362198 1309230 1321061 1311962 1296075 1340723 1210570 1840092 1516868 1880363 1929976 1799620 1847993 1814929 1781751 1874752 1771636 2577626 1378790 1777963 1761190 1671955 1700405 1665417 1636080 1725492 1587021 2338459 1304245 1626324 1580188 1509537 1470478 1470477 1443019 1492464 1371804 2421221 1433256 1794182 1839502 1718173 1772687 1720886 1704958 1823723 1623580 2575884 1592563 1741827 1792881 1731310 1741567 1700590 1693561 1761100 1661760 2011475 285076 245725 235985 270844 231612 229334 229769 238032 308340 220300 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 5292038423059574249887540877520410546734045737539637265416890153916892054323066 118.45 141.99 142.64 137.20 137.79 135.79 133.03 139.92 131.46 182.33 (9) Four images from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image2/sequence/claire/color/ +three images from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image2/sequence/mall/color/ + one images from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image2/sequence/mit/color/ + four images from ftp://ipl.rpi.edu/pub/image2/sequence/mobile/color/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mmf CLAIR000 81761 69718 79754 95140 105641 101327 83643 77892 126580 CLAIR010 80883 68992 77877 93681 103943 99013 82533 77176 124720 CLAIR020 81053 69327 78194 94202 104251 99350 82992 77496 125908 CLAIR030 82871 70964 79800 95943 106313 101965 84894 79100 127502 MALL001 3484685 3157894 3252068 3530060 3636231 4288858 3193595 3112084 3528447 MALL025 3460992 3137013 3229796 3499001 3604883 4213261 3170868 3092492 3493198 MALL050 3468321 3136249 3226071 3495183 3606105 4161126 3167124 3089572 3490386 MIT000 1723794 1623498 1824084 2055812 1966668 2715931 2080402 1564860 2301387 MOBILE02 643602 600329 634305 730645 677610 852592 669433 558684 707889 MOBILE14 638628 596623 629199 722781 670632 850733 663642 554664 700018 MOBILE27 634333 593221 625410 717851 666190 845788 660489 551664 695352 MOBILE39 634450 594320 626397 718030 665826 844981 662194 552780 695017 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 12 150153731371814814362955158483291591429319174925146018091338846416116404 221.86 112.15 102.46 107.27 118.37 118.86 143.21 109.06 100% 120.37 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c2 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 94293 115522 108165 120046 110149 109238 108279 113351 111614 128281 93584 114122 107390 119058 108953 107600 106895 112224 109865 125583 94653 114563 108075 119327 109997 108765 107886 113155 110195 126270 96295 116781 110490 121484 112021 111026 110032 115084 112191 128985 3261239 3952775 3960908 3716526 3809705 3719413 3563702 3842517 3662035 5408132 3240970 3918147 3934874 3686097 3790777 3687677 3540274 3823266 3632035 5371162 3238404 3910712 3926799 3687561 3787917 3688779 3539635 3820279 3635280 5326871 2493634 2480391 2898796 2838028 2732186 2733759 2700463 2770480 2077801 3377909 736179 847424 855574 815686 824216 811337 791290 832466 699895 995971 729541 838197 852491 809011 817142 805205 784559 825100 693241 991628 726852 833308 849611 805561 813821 801253 781130 821811 688033 989772 730367 834968 852469 808071 816502 803885 784074 824537 687646 988930 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 5536011180769101856564217646456178333861748793716918219180142701621983123959494 116.04 135.01 138.66 131.80 133.19 130.61 126.36 134.55 121.14 178.95 (10) All images from ftp://ftp.kodak.com/www/images/dental/ ERI32 UHIC Arhangel BOA UFA32 UFA32 RKIVE BMF RAR Name (none) m -mm -m15 -m4-mx -m5-mu16 -mt3 -f-s-q9 -m5-mm CARB2CAN 993769 898584 936297 1075562 1138597 1172436 916901 845356 1116772 CARB2CAR 296452 263208 295544 330456 311433 298795 305162 261068 578188 CAR3CAN 1061301 950284 979866 1072631 1134066 1088604 973196 934660 1060242 CARB3CAR 243686 211213 247769 275226 359737 236251 353027 225608 431898 DARKACC 545468 504988 530142 687037 684533 843249 578244 490872 910832 EKTAMAT 472762 424903 436766 564040 543690 583207 478657 425924 765142 EKTASPEE 395264 387144 385541 547934 512830 852998 451687 356396 701221 EKTAVIS 834696 777764 815157 982611 1031953 1101376 830360 769780 1155857 GBXCHEM 546607 502080 502555 658859 624709 730790 569881 494308 914595 INPHOTO1 484388 451314 456673 604730 575558 681904 516455 452876 842721 INPHOTO2 187940 183351 176314 272996 226636 295884 225758 173836 373548 LEAD 407202 393487 391543 559737 474299 599388 447882 365064 785034 LIDOCAN1 508947 478928 479331 650886 618150 737522 557414 452216 879598 LIDOCAN2 543898 511868 531292 678843 666587 781034 586336 507512 879847 LIDOCAR2 137573 135714 132419 203863 156624 235526 160936 126768 274582 LIDOCARP 133096 127275 128485 194201 153480 236097 153277 121656 264398 MARCAINE 946532 841807 886975 1002590 1059901 1075685 862858 803408 1035825 MCARPULE 281102 246155 288117 314255 296973 286056 299895 258040 540264 RAPIDACC 482819 454240 451340 606150 563171 711308 520867 440184 826788 READYMAT 339024 318991 316798 442366 402671 532930 368651 308520 667350 READYPRO 388039 355675 351558 455886 421036 500346 397226 347588 703310 RPXOMAT 533613 499718 499252 684310 657346 867125 571919 489264 874966 SCREENS 425270 410498 417858 527848 512920 608890 471638 408416 768379 SILVER 321132 311241 309425 452946 396015 554407 370483 298540 625957 SYRINGE 917491 831562 853078 931499 1009977 902986 859457 800344 941529 TMATG 524356 453641 465280 600199 581720 606430 503366 456832 742553 TMATH 560117 499161 511860 660384 632840 707952 556470 497188 910724 TMATL 453001 413132 426714 570913 547656 596299 489565 407744 764605 ULTRA 413012 394802 398007 544303 498676 652025 462757 382124 760201 XOMAT 624011 555216 581083 731818 716958 790756 622270 555908 969131 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 30 150025681378794414183039178850791751074219868256154625951345800023066057 535.00 111.47 102.45 105.38 132.89 130.11 147.63 114.89 100% 171.39 Locoe Display -i --same -bpng CompuShow Alchemy ESP Pkzip -N -c2 (level=9; filter_type=1...5) auto ---n /mm2 /ml7 -ex 1 2 3 4 5 (5) (4) 959148 1242845 1224818 1155712 1164986 1152865 1139767 1182365 1176621 1551393 513421 408082 437415 421957 421820 422662 406134 456047 331293 421784 985021 1219434 1226376 1160539 1221102 1165719 1149741 1232598 1159737 1364200 378653 323312 361744 351921 343402 347982 329758 370349 391216 337755 737184 827635 774206 841770 772146 775203 768078 810768 725168 1089792 606783 652198 605035 689623 597685 596311 588306 630390 581112 746704 656337 693753 678234 728933 648774 648774 649184 690396 560116 1177697 946653 1134487 1114850 1138856 1061058 1054946 1037120 1095945 1072831 1435271 676690 734496 677459 771159 668298 670053 662429 697353 664500 863671 714404 702611 710149 767897 670048 660998 656083 708562 611428 857722 363919 337308 318474 375527 312508 311919 306331 332902 250488 396581 746540 700264 624629 711246 643268 640534 638675 682108 509487 872088 735876 773118 722409 800399 720890 712916 704425 764668 663708 982718 735292 796972 795022 869147 754892 747956 732920 793131 715258 1012226 272863 245625 228282 265291 229542 228609 225404 238439 171988 296543 266187 242217 228175 259304 228100 227036 227867 234794 169009 308119 891524 1162260 1139365 1074523 1092915 1082109 1071391 1112177 1088830 1458480 426617 380380 413681 403426 398337 399897 381437 428214 319090 403578 634775 693421 650321 737519 631782 631078 621697 661718 599540 857478 507706 508013 462510 549200 464299 459559 453036 496012 435008 660097 510965 505707 473957 560549 461917 462761 454490 483350 453591 575662 671362 782924 723389 815396 701761 701122 689156 734044 697321 1041211 659684 640063 652468 711143 622377 618998 615362 658321 547159 809460 570099 556508 537955 601187 513395 512241 510693 544707 428554 759493 870374 1091075 1109040 1024632 1098894 1034520 1032422 1115109 1031980 1165994 598358 671258 622700 715824 595071 593912 584388 622496 619988 746271 686653 751162 689435 791845 683414 682904 672543 718493 671137 877454 642233 678412 631696 724955 625503 623758 617462 662638 587825 785954 689747 666220 622164 703029 638842 621642 618977 678181 532639 884831 754491 843342 786281 872395 773581 772510 761981 810652 757749 997871 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 9409559209651022024223921594904197606071956149419307257206469271852437125738098 144.22 155.78 150.41 160.46 146.83 145.35 143.46 153.41 137.64 191.24

[[4]] Comments

How to download archivers:

ERI32 3.6fre : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Bay/1995/eri36fre.zip (126K) Arhangel 1.36: http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Lab/6606/arh136.zip (44K) Rkive 1.92b1 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Peaks/9463/rkv192b1.zip (129K) Ufa32 0.04b1 : ftp://ftp.simtel.net/pub/simtelnet/win95/compress/ufa004b1.zip (64K) Pkzip 2.04g : ftp://ftp.simtel.net/pub/simtelnet/msdos/arcers/pkz204g.exe (197K) BMF 0.4 : ftp://ftp.simtel.net/pub/simtelnet/msdos/arcers/bmf_040b.zip (172K) Rar 2.50b3 : ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack/rar250b3.exe (269K) BOA 0.58b : ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack/boa058.zip (74K) UHarc 0.2 : ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack/uharc02.zip (99K) UHic 1.0 : ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack/uhic10.zip (52K) Esp 1.92 : ftp://ftp.elf.stuba.sk/pub/pc/pack/esp_v192.exe (68K) JPEG-LS : http://www.hpl.hp.com/loco/locoX900.zip (375K)

Some homepages:

Arhangel 1.36: http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Lab/6606/ Ufa32 0.04b1 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Lakes/9584 Rkive 1.92b1 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Peaks/9463/ mirror : http://members.tripod.com/~malcolmt/ Rar 2.50b3 : http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Lakes/2797 mirror : http://www.rarsoft.com Pkzip 2.04g : http://www.pkware.com Esp 1.92 : http://www.hszk.bme.hu/~s8335pil JPEG-LS : http://www.hpl.hp.com/loco/

What's new:

New versions of archivers were tested: Arhangel 1.36, Rar 2.50b3, BMF 0.4, and also > a software implementation of JPEG-LS, the > new ISO standard for lossless and near-lossless compression of continuous > tone images. The standard is based on Hewlett-Packard Laboratories' LOCO-I > algorithm, a fact reflected in the names of the programs. The "comp.compression Frequently Asked Questions" document describes it in > [16] What is the state of the art in lossless image compression? > ... > JPEG-LS is the emerging ISO standard for lossless/near-lossless > compression of continuous-tone images. Three lossless JPEG programs mentioned in comp.compression FAQ - > [15] Where can I get image compression programs? > ftp://havefun.stanford.edu/pub/jpeg/JPEGv1.2.1.tar.Z (has lossless mode) > ftp://ftp.cs.cornell.edu/pub/multimed/ljpg.tar.Z (lossless jpeg) > http://idt.net/~dclunie/jpegls.html (lossless jpeg by David Clunie) were not tested at all: no executables were found in these packages; C sources only, and other interesting texts (readme files, copyright and portability notices, test images, etc.) The third link reports that > It only handles one component (ie. grayscale images) for now. while the forth desirable link from that section [15] > ppm2pz: (lossless 24-bit image compression) > http://www.jyu.fi/~kuru/compression.html seems to be not valid (since 1997, by the way). Unfortunately the results of > the revolutionary lossless > image-compression engine > "The New Standard for Lossless PhotoQuality Compression" (visit http://www.bitjazz.com/index.html now) were NOT included: the evaluation version from http://www.bitjazz.com/binaries/PhotoJazzSetup.exe was unable to losslessly extract test images it compressed. Exactly so: > Note: a magic watermark overlay is applied to PhotoJazz images > saved during evaluation. Some WARNINGS again: ESP 1.92 (release) has some bugs and was unable to correctly uncompress some test images: they are (re)named in our tests as AYMAR,GELSNGER,NACHTSHM,OTELLINI,VADASZ,YU1,DP081897,L217C-34,PS091597. ESP doesn't even report something like "CRC fails"...As if everything is OK. New Rkive 1.92b1 was unable to losslessly uncompress most images from 6th, 7th and 8th tests, for example AYMAR,BARRETT,CARTER,CRAWFORD,DAVIES,DUNLAP,DYESS,GELSNGER,GEYER,GILL... It reports "ERROR: File fails CRC check!. Archive failed integrity check." Bmp2Eri 6.01 was renamed to Eri32 3.6fre (freeware version of ERI32) because it can compress not only images in .BMP format, but also sound in .WAV or .669 format (with "-38" switch) and any data (with "-38a"). THE LATEST RELEASE, and eight previous versions of these tests can be found at http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Bay/1995/

The final part

> [[5]] PLEASE read THIS before replying to this article was removed from this report, but can be easily found at http://www.geocities.com/SiliconValley/Bay/1995/artest10.html Send your suggestions, comments to ratush@srsc-gw.sscc.ru With best kind regards, RAO Inc.